iLinuxOS Talk

A real suggestion from a normal Linux user

append delete ClickNin

Hi, I'm ClickNin, and just come across this distribution recently.

Before anything futher, I want to say that this is a suggestion, my suggestion on the future of this distribution, and my personal thinking. Please don't consider it a hate, and don't create additional problem. I hate toxic people, and I'm making this thread from what I'm thinking. Well, that's all.

Firstly, this distribution looks like a OS for a Kid Tablet. I saw the screenshot, and thats why I say this. The icons, the functions, the button and the UI design, all are way too "friendly". The most user friendly distribution doesn't look like this. This should be much more simple. If you want a OS for the children and not for normal user, then continue leave it like this, else, remake it. Use a desktop environment like Xfce4, GNOME or Cinnamon. Or if lightweight is your focus, use i3 or DWM.

Secondly, this distribution are way too bloated. Preinstalling everything isn't a good idea at all. A software manager, a commandline-based package manager should be better. The user should have the permission to install whatever they want and not using preinstalled software. It is consider bloat on every OS. Even Windows's preinstalled app doesn't too much. 500 apps is too bloated. The image file are way too large for a Linux distro. Even MacOS is just 12 GB (last time I tried), and the ".img" format are very weird (except for a guy that doesn't know how to use a basic UNIX tool like "xorriso").

Finally, even if Debian 10 are LTS, it's way too old for a distribution. Consider learning Linux From Scratch to create your own distribution, or use another distribution as the base. I would recommends Ubuntu 20.04 Focal Fossa Base Image, but you can choose whatever you want. And, please choose a better name, "iLinux" are too "Applify", and in fact the "i" character are used in almost every product by Apple, and that can cause confusion.

So, make something that user friendly, professional and productive are the key to a good distribution. That's my own suggestion though, I don't want problem, but I want to talk peacefully.

Thanks and wish best to you.

Reply RSS

Replies

append delete #1. AaronTechic dude

I agree with you ClickNin.

append delete #2. ClickNin

EDIT: The user friendly, professional, productive, flexible and the freedom are the key.

append delete #3. ILUNIX BETTER

ILUNUX IS BETTER U CUNT!!!

append delete #4. iLinux Support Team

“The image file are way too large for a Linux distro. Even MacOS is just 12 GB (last time I tried), and the ".img" format are very weird (except for a guy that doesn't know how to use a basic UNIX tool like "xorriso").”

You also refer to the Raspberry Pi OS developers too and to all developers that create Operating Systems for Raspberry Pi, right? They distribute their Operating Systems via ".img" format too.

You also refer to the EndlessOS developers too, right? They distribute their Operating System via ".img" format too.

All those developers don't know how to use a basic UNIX tool like "xorriso", right?

We believe that Operating Systems must be judged by their innovations and not by the size of their download.

That being said, you can use any Linux Distro you like.

We believe in Good Software.

We don't care if it is Free, Paid, Open Source or Proprietary, as long as it does not violate our Freedoms and our Rights.

We respect every User and his choices.

After all, there is a reason behind these choices.

We do not hate Microsoft Windows, macOS or other Linux distributions.

We believe that users should use what they think and feel is best for them.

And we deeply respect any User or Developer that sits in front of a computer with a dream to create something wonderful!

When you understand our mentality and stop being a fanatic, then we will be able to discuss...

append delete #5. AaronTechnic dude

“You also refer to the Raspberry Pi OS developers too and to all developers that create Operating Systems for Raspberry Pi, right? They distribute their Operating Systems via ".img" format too.”

iLinux Support Guy, or whoever you are, you can't compare Raspberry Pi OS to an amd64 distro.

I don't use Raspberry Pi myself, but as far as I know, the main storage device is an SD card, although you can use others. And to install, you need to use the RPi burning tool, and since .img format is not read-only, you can use it after setting your user up.

A typical amd64 distro would be provided in an .iso to install to a disk. However iLinux seems to be a distro to be used on an USB disk. About EndlessOS, the last time I downloaded it, it was provided as an .iso.

After that you just say blah blah blah, nothing related to what @ClickNin said.

“When you understand our mentality and stop being a fanatic, then we will be able to discuss...”

He is just giving suggestions for your distro. It just looks like you can't accept the fact thst your distro looks like a kids tablet.

append delete #6. iLinux Support Team

@AaronTechnic dude

Do your homework. EndlessOS's original distribution was in ".img" format.

Some interesting reading:

Why ISO was retired

https://bkhome.org/news/202112/why-iso-was-retired.html

---

Of course we can compare Linux Distros. They are Linux Distros and that's why we compare them.

---

“However iLinux seems to be a distro to be used on an USB disk.”

Do your homework. https://ilinuxos.com/install-requirements.html

---

“He is just giving suggestions for your distro. It just looks like you can't accept the fact thst your distro looks like a kids tablet.”

We disagree.

It's not bad to disagree.

That's the beauty of Linux.

There is something for everyone and freedom of choice.

append delete #7. Fotini

@ClickNin

You "Linux Mafia" thugs just don't get it do you?

No matter what you say or do, iLinux continues to win more users day by day.

iLinux is here to stay. Get over it.

append delete #8. ClickNin

iLinux Support Team

You does provide a point, but not answering to the rest of my suggestions.
Both ISO and IMG format are for stored image data. Even if ISO format is retired, almost every distro are using it. You can't say that Raspberry Pi OS use the "img" format and count that, it's like comparing a SD Card to a Hard Drive. Since RPi OS are for ARM and designed for SD Card, you can't just compare it right away.

MacOS does use IMG format (last time I checked) but used it with their own format called Apple File System (APFS) or Hierarchical File System Plus (HFS+).

EndlessOS are just a OS come preloaded with software, for Offline usage. They also have a somewhat nice UI (in my opinion). iLinux OS are just a bloated OS which have the UI for a Kids Tablet.

The rest of your messages is likely copy-paste. I saw it a lot, a lot of time on this forum. In fact this forum doesn't even have a fitter, and toxic peoples are full here. No register, no login? Fine, but toxic peoples here making this distribution, and this forum polluted. As I said, I don't want any additional problems, I just want to talk peacefully.

if you don't care about what I'm said, just go away and pretend that this message, and my suggestions doesn't exist.

append delete #9. AaronTechnic

It's a shame that @Fotini and @iLinux Support Team isn't open to any suggestions.

" We believe that Operating Systems must be judged by their innovations and not by the size of their download."

What kind of innovation have you done?

“We believe in Good Software. We don't care if it is Free, Paid, Open Source or Proprietary, as long as it does not violate our Freedoms and our Rights.”

Violates your freedom and rights, yeah, the proprietary software bundled with iLinux violates your freedom and rights.

“And we deeply respect any User or Developer that sits in front of a computer with a dream to create something wonderful!”

I don't get what's wonderful about iLinux. You are providing a 20 GB download in a zipped archive. You can just use other formats and achieve smaller sizes.

“When you understand our mentality and stop being a fanatic, then we will be able to discuss...”

@ClickNin is not being a fanatic. Your distro looks like a literal kids tablet!

“Why ISO was retired

https://bkhome.org/news/202112/why-iso-was-retired.html”

I agree with you. I think it's okay for distros to use ISO because of live media and DVD compatibility.

“You "Linux Mafia" thugs just don't get it do you?”

Wow. Calling us "Linux Mafia" for giving suggestions. Have an open mind.

“No matter what you say or do, iLinux continues to win more users day by day.”

How many actually use iLinux? It's literally unheard of. I don't think 1% of the Linux community even knows what this distro is.

append delete #10. root

@AaronTechnic @ClickNin

Well, let's talk about the so called "Linux Community"...

It's no secret that 99% of all those "Linux Community Websites & Linux YouTube Chanells & Linux IRC Chat Channels", promote 5-10 Linux Distros out of 100's. This is not random.

And it goes deeper that that. The hostile behaviour of this "Linux Mafia Army" when you talk about other distros than the ones they push, is classic...

All those "Linux Community Websites & Linux YouTube Chanells" sell your browsing data to 1000's of capitalist companies by spying on you via Cookies, so even in most Linux distros (FOSS or not) you are the product...

I am not saying that it's bad to want to make money, but if at the same time you are preaching Internet Freedom and FOSS, it's a bit hypocritical at best.

So, don't lecture us about the so called "Linux Community".

We know the subversive and covert tactics of your "Dark Web Gang": Online Mob/Swarm Misinformation, Online Mob/Swarm Slandering, Online Mob/Swarm Character Assassination, Online Mob/Swarm Psychological Operations, Online Mob/Swarm Sabotage.

You may have positioned yourself at the backbone of the internet, pulling strings from the shadows, but you are not invisible.

append delete #11. Linux Soul

@AaronTechnic @ClickNin

Use whatever distro you like. Or even better build a distro as you like it. Why bother with iLinux if it's so bad for you as you describe it?

Linux is about freedom of choice. Not about attacking another distro because you don't like it. If you don't like it don't use it. We like it and we use it. It doesn't get any simpler than that.

append delete #12. Ok Boomer

Ok Boomer

append delete #13. ClickNin

Okay okay, I will not rather talking about this distribution anymore. But there is something that I feel wrong here.

Your End User License is actually looks like a license for a proprietary software. As iLinux Support Team said, he believe in every software, as long as it doesn't violate your Freedoms and Rights. But, as you may know, Linux kernel is licensed under GPLv2.

GPLv2 is designed to give you the freedom to share and change free software, to make sure the software is free for all users, free software here is referring to freedom, not price. However iLinux seems to do the reserve...
I don't see anywhere the source code, the script or the source to build the full iLinux image. You guys are using Linux kernel, and Linux kernel is licensed under GPLv2, you guys are violating it.
The GPLv2 license can be read from here: https://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-2.0.en.html

In your End User License (which shouldn't be existed), you separate it to 2 license, one for normal users, and one for OEM. And what? OEM have to pay 20 Euros per computer? There is no "License Fee" here, what cost you only is your time and your bandwidth (a few companies like Canonical or RedHat provides optional commercial support for enterprise or corporation which I think iLinux is not in this case). Also in the End User License, just read it a few times and again, this is a proprietary license. Before you saying that you can sell a FOSS product, GPL does allow that. But since Linux is GPL, again. You can't include a GPL product (Linux) inside a Proprietary license (which yours does). Show me trustworthy proof about that, either private (though Discord) or here. Why would you not allowing peoples to modify your OS, why not redistributes it, why not change the name and logo? GPL allow that! It's freedom.

You are using the term "Free software" incorrectly here. We are referring to Freedom of the users, not price! You can't prevent people from using your OS if they refuse to follow your license. You are violating GPL right now. "Intellectual Property"? You didn't own Linux. You might own your UI design, but that doesn't cover anything.

Remove that proprietary license.

Linux Kernel is maintained by The Linux Foundation. No one own Linux. It's always open source. Linus Torvalds is the chief maintainer still, and he has the final say on major changes to the Linux kernel.

That's all I want to say. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.
Wish you the best.

Resources & References:
Linux Kernel Archives - Frequently Asked Questions: https://kernel.org/category/faq.html
GNU General Public License Version 2.0: https://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-2.0.en.html
iLinux OS End User License: https://ilinuxos.com/license.html

append delete #14. iLinux Support Team

@ClickNin

Do your homework.

Read the iLinux OS Licenses again. Very carefully.

append delete #15. ClickNin

iLinux Support Team

Point me directly to the point, I don't have time.
Plus, I have read it, 5 times, in a row.

My Discord is ClickNin#4252.

I can show you the proof right now, if you like it.

append delete #16. Debian User

@iLinux Support Team, this is ridiculous.

Get ti the point. You keep saying "Do your homework" although I have read the licenses. Why don't you just get to the point? Anyways your license it worse than what a commercial distro like Ubuntu would have.

append delete #17. iLinux Support Team

@ClickNin

The Licenses are the point.

Read them again.

append delete #18. ClickNin

@Debian User

Yeah, but I don't think Ubuntu is a commercial distro, correct me if I'm wrong :).
Canonical provides optional commercial support for Ubuntu, but the distro is open source and free to use.

append delete #19. iLinux Support Team

@Debian User

If you don't like the License use another Linux distribution or built your own Linux distribution with a License of your liking.

As Linux Soul said earlier:

“Linux is about freedom of choice. Not about attacking another distro because you don't like it. If you don't like it don't use it. We like it and we use it. It doesn't get any simpler than that.”

append delete #20. ClickNin

@iLinux Support Team

I swear that I have read them again, for 10 times.
Bring me to the direct point, stop being a jerk.

append delete #21. ClickNin

@iLinux Support Team

And again, this isn't only about license of a distro. But this is GPL Violation.

append delete #22. iLinux Support Team

@ClickNin

If you don't like the License use another Linux distribution or built your own Linux distribution with a License of your liking.

As Linux Soul said earlier:

“Linux is about freedom of choice. Not about attacking another distro because you don't like it. If you don't like it don't use it. We like it and we use it. It doesn't get any simpler than that."

append delete #23. ClickNin

@iLinux Support Team

You still didn't answered my question yet!
Bring me to your point.

append delete #24. ClickNin

Okay then. I'm not going to bother you again.
This is enough.

append delete #25. iLinux Support Team

@ClickNin

For a person that is not an iLinux user and hates iLinux so much, you take too much time out of your life to be involved in this Community. Why is that? Not that we will ever censor you but what's driving you?

Are you a member of the "Linux Community" that @root talked about earlier?

append delete #26. ClickNin

@iLinux Support Team

I'm not hate iLinux or anything. I'm just a normal Linux user, like any others.
I'm just saying my own personal opinion, giving suggestions and that's all.
I'm not hate who is behind this distribution, I know that everyone, even if their product are bad or not, they at least are putting efforts into it, and they deserve to be respected.

It's depend on you to heard and following my suggestions or not. That's your choice. Freedom of choice.
As you said, free of speech.

Well, I got to go now. Wish you the best.

append delete #27. ClickNin

As I said on the start, I just want to talk peacefully.

append delete #28. iLinux Support Team

@ClickNin

We disagree on many things but every honest suggestion is welcome.

But in order to make substantiated suggestions on a product, you have to use it first.

And since this is a Free product, it won't cost you anything to give it a try.

Try first, then judge.

Wish you the best.

append delete #29. Free Software Man

The distro is not Free Software. It's a gratis free product.

append delete #30. root

@Free Software Man

What's your point?

append delete #31. Free Software Dude

My point is that @iLinux Support Team and @iLinux Creator is using the term "Free Software" incorrectly.

“We don't care if it is Free, Paid, Open Source or Proprietary, as long as it does not violate our Freedoms and our Rights.”

It's up to you if you want proprietary garbage in your distro. However proprietary software does NOT respect your freedom and rights.

“And since this is a Free product, it won't cost you anything to give it a try.”

Okay, but is the product free as in freedom or free as in price? If free as in price it is a violation of the GPL.

append delete #32. someunknown

Yeah @Free Software Dude

Proprietary Software and DRM are something that is designed to take away your freedom rights. You can learn more about Free Software Foundation's Anti-DRM Campaign here: https://www.defectivebydesign.org/

Freedom here is about the freedom of the user, not the price.
About the hardware, yeah I agree that some of them are proprietary, however with the time being that will eventually changes.

@iLinux Support Team point is that they doesn't care whatever type of a software it is, as long as it doesn't violating their own rights. That's fine, every person has different opinion.

I agree with @ClickNin that your license is a GPL Violation. Of course I have tried iLinux, and as myself doesn't use it as a daily driver, my kids are using it (a modified version that has 95% of the default preinstalled software removed) since the design fit them.

Thanks you for reading.

append delete #33. Stallman Supporter

I agree @someunknown

append delete #34. iLinux Support Team

Concerning Free Open Source Software (FOSS):

Philosophically and ethically we agree but every day practicality needs things get done.

We support FOSS but in the real world 99% of Devices, Appliances, Machinery and Vehicles YOU USE run on Proprietary Software.

The Computer or Tablet or Phone you are using right now to Preach FOSS runs on Proprietary Software (Embedded in the Hardware or not).

This is pure hypocrisy.

We agree that FOSS is good but we need things get done and if FOSS does not suit us we'll use whatever software does the job.

That's what FOSS Fanatics don't get. Users need things get done. Now.

Mac, iPhone and iPad run on Proprietary Software and still they changed the world and gave us tremendous power.

Proprietary Software is not always about removing or limiting our Freedoms and our Rights.

It can be about User Experience Consistency, Quality Control and Stability. At least that is the case with iLinux OS.

We value Freedom and Trasnparency above all and that's why all the Proprietary Code we have written for iLinux OS is Scriptable and available for Security Auditing to everyone: https://ilinuxos.com/technical-specifications.html

append delete #35. tototrr

Here is my suggestion though:

1) Instead of pre bundle all applications at once, make a simple GUI app where people can install these apps within 1 click.
2) Make iLinux smaller, that would help people with limited bandwidth, or with limited disk space. Not everyone can afford a 64GB USB Drive!
3) Make the design consist with each other. It was too inconsistency.
4) Update grammar, there is too much grammar errors.
5) Provide the source code, as GPL. That only provide a benefit and freedom.

append delete #36. iLinux Support Team

@tototrr

1) No. If you want a Linux Distribution like that, use another Linux Distribution or develop it your self.

2) No. We are in 2022. Bandwidth constantly increases and 64 GB USB Sticks are cheap.

3) The Design is consistent. If you disagree please provide substantiated examples.

4) The grammar is fine. If you disagree please provide substantiated examples.

5) The source code is provided. iLinux OS is based on Unmodified Debian 10 Stable and Debian is GPL. All the Proprietary Code we have written for iLinux OS is Scriptable and available for Security Auditing to everyone: https://ilinuxos.com/technical-specifications.html

---

Having said that, your persistence in trying to dictate to us what to do with our product, has only three possible explanations:

1) You want to be a part of our Team.

2) You want us to release our Proprietary Code as FOSS in order to profit from it.

3) You are a member of the "Linux Community" @root talked about earlier:

“Well, let's talk about the so called "Linux Community"...

It's no secret that 99% of all those "Linux Community Websites & Linux YouTube Chanells & Linux IRC Chat Channels", promote 5-10 Linux Distros out of 100's. This is not random.

And it goes deeper that that. The hostile behaviour of this "Linux Mafia Army" when you talk about other distros than the ones they push, is classic...

All those "Linux Community Websites & Linux YouTube Chanells" sell your browsing data to 1000's of capitalist companies by spying on you via Cookies, so even in most Linux distros (FOSS or not) you are the product...

I am not saying that it's bad to want to make money, but if at the same time you are preaching Internet Freedom and FOSS, it's a bit hypocritical at best.

So, don't lecture us about the so called "Linux Community".

We know the subversive and covert tactics of your "Dark Web Gang": Online Mob/Swarm Misinformation, Online Mob/Swarm Slandering, Online Mob/Swarm Character Assassination, Online Mob/Swarm Psychological Operations, Online Mob/Swarm Sabotage.

You may have positioned yourself at the backbone of the internet, pulling strings from the shadows, but you are not invisible.”

append delete #37. Richard Stallman

@iLinux Support Team I didn't talk about that. I know users needs to get things done but I was talking about the GPL.

append delete #38. iLinux Support Team

@Richard Stallman

GPL is what it is.

Our License is something different.

If you want a Linux Distribution that is full GPL, use another Linux Distribution or develop it your self.

append delete #39. root

@iLinux Support Team

I think that its #2:

They want you to release your Proprietary Code as FOSS in order to profit from it.

It's a classic tactic of the "Linux Mafia Army", to apply negative psychologican pressure in order to discredit and discourage developers, steal their code and profit from it in any way.

And because they plan far ahead, I think they fear of what iLinux may become.

append delete #40. popeye

uhh im not getting into this but
i think with FOSS you can get profit, but that is optional
of course you can sell it, but if people want they can compile it from source instead of buying it, it some sort of donation only lmfao
if FOSS program is selled, then the source is still free, and the user may compile the source instead, no one forcing them to buy it. thats how it works, take crossover as a example (a upgraded version of wine)
ofc, @tototrr if you disagree with ilinux then use other distro xd
@root idk if there is a "linux mafia" here lol

append delete #41. swan

@root

where do u get all this info about linux mafia?

append delete #42. root

@swan

I can use a computer.

append delete #43. BobBob

"Linux Community" is a batch of arrogant mediocre thugs at best...

Explore Linux yourself and stick only to isolated healthy forums and communities.

append delete #44. ok boomer123

ok boomer

Reply

(Leave this as-is, it’s a trap!)

There is no need to “Register”. Just enter the same Name + Password of your choice every time.

Use Format Text to add links, quotes, bold, italic and more. You can also upload images or videos or archived web pages or multicontent or use any upload website.

Moderators: iLinux Creator, iLinux Support Team

  1. Home
  2. » iLinux OS - Opinions

FORMAT TEXT :: HELP :: TERMS OF USE

iLinuxOS :: Innovations :: Apps :: Games :: Servers :: Control :: Screenshots :: Compare :: Download :: Install :: Updates :: Support :: Team :: Business :: Donate :: License :: YouTube

Linux® is the registered trademark of Linus Torvalds in the U.S. and other countries. All Copyrights, Logos, Trademarks and Intellectual Properties in iLinuxOS and in this website are property of their respective owner. All the rest Copyright 2015- George Dimitrakopoulos and iLinuxOS. All Rights Reserved.